Russian and Chinese Scholars Share Experience of Transformation of Doctoral Education
The Russian and Chinese postgraduate education systems originally borrowed their institutional frameworks from the Soviet Union. However, in the 21st century, they have evolved along different paths. While key performance indicators for postgraduate programmes in Russia are declining, China is seeing a rapid increase in the number of postgraduate students. These contrasting trajectories and the reforms undertaken in each country in recent decades were the focus of a roundtable discussion held as part of the 25th Yasin (April) International Academic Conference.
Evgeniy Terentev
The roundtable was part of a major research project titled ‘Transformation of Doctoral Education in China and Russia,’ conducted jointly by the HSE Institute of Education and the Institute of Education at Tsinghua University. The session was moderated by Evgeniy Terentev, Director of the HSE Institute of Education.
Professor Ma Yonghong, Director of the Graduate Education Research Centre at Beihang University's Institute of Higher Education, emphasised that over the past fifty years, China has been adapting its system for training researchers to meet the evolving needs of the economy and society. Previously limited to individual universities, both academic and professional postgraduate education are now being developed on a national scale. In several key areas, China’s model has outperformed many of its European counterparts.
A new wave of reforms launched in 2019 aims to improve the quality of postgraduate training, shifting the focus from the number of publications to the quality of dissertations—particularly the significance and practical value of research outcomes. Requirements for academic supervisors have been tightened, financial and organisational support for students has been enhanced, and the management system has been improved. Professional postgraduate education is being introduced, with plans for professional degrees to account for up to one-third of all awards by 2025.
‘These measures are designed to make postgraduate education a source of strategically important professionals for priority sectors—from fundamental science to high-tech manufacturing,’ Ma Yonghong noted.
Wang Chuanyi, Deputy Director of the Research Centre for Education Strategic and National Planning at Tsinghua University and a contributor to the ‘Transformation of Doctoral Education in China and Russia’ project, reflected on the initial efforts to develop scientific training in post-war China, paying particular attention to the expansion of postgraduate education in the 1970s, including the establishment of a regulatory framework. The second part of his report focused on the changes initiated in the late 1990s and still ongoing today.
Wang Chuanyi highlighted China's intensified efforts to combat academic misconduct and the establishment of a ‘five-mode’ quality assurance system based on cooperation among universities, government agencies, professional associations, industry, and civil society institutions.
Concluding his presentation, the researcher stated that by 2030–2035, China aims to secure global leadership in doctoral education by increasing the proportion of postgraduate students within the overall student population, focusing on priority areas in science, technology, and medicine, and developing an integrated model of cooperation between the state, universities, industry, and science to train strategically important personnel.
Nikolay Rybakov, Associate Professor at the Centre for Research in Science and Postgraduate Education Development, Lobachevsky University (Nizhny Novgorod), spoke about the impact of the 2013–2015 reforms of postgraduate education and dissertation councils in Russia on PhD thesis defences.
As part of this reform, postgraduate studies were formally classified as a level of education. A large educational component was introduced, and the defence of the candidate dissertation was removed from the standard curriculum. Graduates instead defended a qualifying project that did not result in the awarding of a degree, and took a qualification exam that assessed their teaching competencies. Simultaneously, the requirements for awarding academic degrees were significantly tightened.
As a result, from 2013 to 2021, admissions to postgraduate programmes in Russia fell by 28%, the total number of postgraduates dropped by 32%, the number of graduates declined by 59%, and the proportion of graduates who completed their studies with a successful dissertation defence fell by 61%. The social sciences and humanities were hit harder than the natural sciences.
Nikita Smirnov
Nikita Smirnov, Junior Research Fellow at the HSE Centre of Sociology of Higher Education, presented findings from a study on the effectiveness of grant support for doctoral students under the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (RFBR) programme in 2019–2020.
The study showed that receiving a grant had a significantly positive effect on the likelihood of successfully defending a PhD thesis—increasing the probability by 70% compared to those who did not receive a grant, all other factors being equal. Nikita Smirnov attributes this to the fact that a grant reduces the need for outside employment, allowing students to focus on their dissertations, and also helps mitigate negative psychological effects, as receiving a grant serves as a form of academic recognition.
The grant also positively influences timely thesis defence and publication activity—an effect that Prof. Ma Yonghong also noted in relation to practices in China. However, the conclusion that targeted grant support is a valid tool for enhancing postgraduate performance and research productivity comes with two caveats. First, the format of the programme is crucial—the grant must be long-term and specifically targeted. Second, the relative weight of various forms of support remains unclear: according to Nikita Smirnov, further research is needed to better understand the combined impact of individual and environmental predictors of success.
Summing up the roundtable, Evgeniy Terentev noted that this is just the beginning of a broader discussion on the development of doctoral education in different countries, and that participants would continue the dialogue across various platforms.
‘China and Russia face major challenges and hold significant ambitions for improving the postgraduate education system—not just in terms of meeting specific performance indicators, but in strengthening its overall contribution to the scientific and technological advancement of our countries,’ concluded the Director of the HSE Institute of Education.
See also:
‘The Most Important Lesson I've Learned at HSE Is the Power of Collaboration’
Jingtao Xu (called Andy in English) earned a Bachelor’s degree in Data Science and Business Analytics at HSE University–Moscow and is now studying on the Master’s in Math of Machine Learning. In this interview with the HSE News Service, Andy talks about his plans to develop his robotics research into a commercial product, how online shopping in Moscow has improved since he first arrived, and why now is a good time to capitalise on Russian–Chinese cooperation.
Nobel Laureate Proposes Solution to Markov Equilibrium Problem
In dynamic games, a Markov equilibrium involves strategies that guide players' behaviour based on the current state of the game, rather than its entire history. This approach is effective when players have access to complete information. But when uncertainty arises in the game—for instance, when players are unsure of who they are dealing with—this approach can become problematic. Eric Maskin, Nobel Laureate in Economics and Professor at Harvard University, addressed this issue in a paper presented at the XXV Yasin (April) International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development held at HSE University from April 15 to 18, 2025.
‘The World Is Becoming More Complex and Less Predictable’: What Scientists Say about the Future
The future is now more difficult for researchers to forecast, and events that are hard to predict are playing an increasingly significant role. But there is good news too: scientists are confident that humanity will adapt to any changes. This was the focus of discussion at the International Symposium ‘Foresight in a Rapidly Changing World,’ which took place as part of the 25th Yasin (April) International Academic Conference.
Fragmentation and Bloc Formation: How the Global Economy is Changing
Sergey Dubinin, former head of the Bank of Russia and Professor of Finance and Credit at the Faculty of Economics at Moscow State University, has delivered an honorary address at the XXV Yasin (April) International Academic Conference. He spoke about the transformation of the global monetary and financial system, as well as the Russian economy.
More Children, More Happiness: HSE Experts Study Impact of Number of Children on Russians' Assessment of Happiness
Russians with children feel happier than those without children. At the same time, the number of children influences the assessment of happiness: the more children Russians have, the happier they feel. These conclusions were outlined inthe report ‘More Children, More Happiness: The Impact of the Number of Children on Russians’ Assessment of Happiness,’ presented at the XXV Yasin (April) International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development, held on April 15–18 at HSE University. The study was conducted by Elena Churilova, Senior Research Fellow, and Dmitry Jdanov, Chief Research Fellowat HSE International Laboratory for Population and Health.
HSE Expands Cooperation with Gulf Countries
HSE University and the Centre for International Policy Research (Qatar) have agreed to collaborate in the field of social sciences, with plans for joint research, academic exchanges, and regular expert engagement. The agreement was signed during the roundtable ‘State Capacity and State Resilience in the Global South,’ held as part of the 25th Yasin (April) International Academic Conference at HSE University.
‘We Grow Old before We Become Rich’: How BRICS Countries Can Achieve Economic Growth
Due to population aging, many countries aiming for economic prosperity have limited time left to undergo economic transformation, according to the honorary report Narratives Versus Reality on Employment and Demography: How Undermining Institutions Can Push Countries Out of the ‘Narrow Corridor’ by Santosh Mehrotra of the University of Bath. The report was presented at the XXV Yasin (April) International Academic Conference.
XXV Yasin (April) Academic Conference Kicks Off at HSE University
The anniversary 25th Yasin (April) International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development will take place from April 15 to 18. This year, over a thousand applications were submitted to present at the conference, of which the Programme Committee selected 381 of the best research papers in their respective fields.
‘HSE Offers a Wealth of Opportunities, but It’s up to You to Take Advantage of Them’
Zhou Jinyu is a third-year student of the Bachelor’s programme ‘Data Science and Business Analytics’ at the Faculty of Computer Science at HSE University. She talked to the HSE News Service about studying on the double-degree programme, her career prospects, her attitude to artificial intelligence, and why it’s important to step out of your comfort zone.
HSE Expands Cooperation with Chinese Universities
An HSE delegation, led by Rector Nikita Anisimov, visited China for negotiations with the administration of the country’s top universities. The parties agreed to expand bilateral scientific and educational collaboration and signed several documents. In particular, a strategic partnership agreement was established with Peking University, one of the oldest and most prestigious educational institutions in China.